Material vs material repair playbook
Understand the different materials and their repair costs, lifespan, maintenance, and difficulty for install when it comes to all types of materials for roofing.
Comparison of Material costs
When you’re comparing repair prices, asphalt shingles usually land at the low end of the scale. They’re simple to work with and widely available, which makes them 30–50% cheaper to repair than most other roofing materials. But every material has its own price range, challenges, and labor demands. Here’s how the numbers shake out:
Asphalt Shingle Roof repairs
Small fixes (a few loose or missing shingles): $200–$500
Mid-level repairs (leaks, flashing, pipe boots): $400–$1,000
Bigger issues (valleys, sections with rot or water intrusion): $800–$2,000
Because asphalt is common and easy to handle, nearly any roofer can work with it.
Metal Roof repairs
Light repairs (loose seams, fasteners, minor rust): $400–$800
Medium repairs (panel swaps, flashing problems): $600–$1,500
Extensive repairs (large damaged sections, structural concerns): $1,200–$3,500
Metal is pricier to repair because it demands specialized tools and a roofer who understands how metal reacts to heat, movement, and waterproofing.
Tile Roof Repairs (clay or concrete)
Minor fixes (a few cracked tiles): $300–$700
Moderate repairs (leaks from underlayment issues): $800–$2,000
Major repairs (large sections, broken support battens): $1,500–$4,000
Tile roofs are unforgiving—step wrong and you break a tile—so experience and precision drive the cost up.
Slate Roof repairs
Small repairs (individual slate pieces): $400–$900
Mid-range repairs (multiple tiles, flashing): $900–$2,500
Large repairs (big areas or structural problems): $2,500–$5,000+
Slate repair requires true specialists, and the materials themselves are expensive or custom-cut, which pushes the price higher.
Wood shake roof repairs
Minor repairs (replace a handful of shakes): $250–$600
Moderate fixes (localized leak or rot): $600–$1,400
Major work (multiple areas, deeper moisture damage): $1,200–$3,000
Shake roofing often hides rot beneath the surface, so repairs can quickly get complex.
Repair difficulty by roofing material
Some roofs are straightforward to fix. Others require a surgeon’s level of precision. Here’s how hard each material is to repair — and why.
Repair difficulty affects:
How long the repair takes
How much the repair costs
How many contractors are even qualified to do it
How likely you are to end up with more damage if the wrong person touches it
Material difficulty is one of the biggest reasons homeowners get burned by the wrong contractor.
Asphalt Shingles — Easiest
Asphalt is the entry-level of roof repairs.
Easy to access
Simple to remove and replace
Widely understood by almost every roofer
Unless the damage is deep (rot, decking issues), asphalt repairs are quick and predictable.
Difficulty: Low
Wood Shake — Moderate
Shake roofs look simple, but repairing them takes finesse.
Each shake interlocks differently
Nails are hidden under overlapping layers
Rot or moisture can spread beyond the visible area
You can’t just “pop off” a shake — you have to work backward through the layers without cracking the surrounding ones.
Difficulty: Medium
Metal Roofing — Moderate to hard
Metal repairs require precision and specialized handling.
You’re dealing with expansion and contraction
Panels are locked or fastened in specific patterns
One wrong move creates new leaks
Only roofers familiar with the specific metal system (standing seam vs. exposed fastener) should touch it.
Difficulty: Medium–High
tile (clay or concrete) — Hard
Tile repairs are tricky for one simple reason: tile breaks easily.
Step in the wrong spot → another tile cracks
Underlayment issues often cause the leak, not the tile itself
Replacement tiles must match color, size, and profile
It’s slow, careful work — break even one extra tile and costs climb.
Difficulty: High
slate — Very hard
Slate work isn’t just a “repair.” It’s a craft.
Tiles are heavy and fragile
Fasteners must be removed without cracking adjacent pieces
Repairs require slate-specific tools and techniques
Only a small percentage of roofers know how to do it right
Slate repairs are surgical and require experience most contractors don’t have.
Difficulty: Very High
Roof Maintenance by material
Different roofs demand different levels of care. Understanding what each type needs helps prevent costly repairs and extends its life.
Asphalt Shingles — low maintenance
Inspect for missing or curling shingles once a year
Clean gutters to prevent water backup
Minor moss or algae cleaning if needed
Asphalt is forgiving and easy to maintain. Most homeowners can handle basic upkeep themselves.
Maintenance Level: Low
Wood Shake — Moderate maintenance
Annual inspections for rot, splits, or insect damage
Keep debris off the roof to prevent moisture buildup
Treat with fire retardant or preservative every few years
Wood shakes require more attention than asphalt. Moisture and mold are the biggest threats.
Maintenance Level: Moderate
Metal Roofing — low to moderate maintenance
Inspect for loose fasteners or seams once a year
Remove leaves, branches, or debris that trap moisture
Check coatings to prevent rust on exposed fasteners
Metal roofs are durable but require periodic inspections to catch small issues before they become leaks.
Maintenance Level: Low–Moderate
tile (clay or concrete)— Moderate to high maintenance
Check for cracked or missing tiles annually
Inspect underlayment for water damage
Clear debris from valleys and gutters
Tiles themselves are long-lasting, but underlayment problems or broken tiles can lead to hidden leaks if not monitored.
Maintenance Level: Moderate–High
slate — high maintenance
Annual inspections by a professional
Replace cracked or missing tiles promptly
Ensure flashings and fasteners remain intact
Slate is incredibly durable, but repairs are complex and expensive if small problems are ignored. Preventative care is critical.
Maintenance Level: High
Roof lifespan by material
Knowing how long your roof lasts helps you plan maintenance, repairs, and eventual replacement. Lifespan varies widely depending on material, installation quality, and environmental conditions.
Asphalt Shingles — 15 to 30 Years
Most common residential roof type
Lifespan depends on shingle quality (three-tab vs. architectural) and weather exposure
Sun, wind, and heavy storms can shorten lifespan
Key Takeaway: Affordable and predictable, but likely to need replacement sooner than other materials.
Wood Shake — 20 to 35 Years
Natural wood, typically cedar
Lifespan affected by moisture, mold, insects, and fire risk
Regular maintenance and protective treatments extend life
Key Takeaway: Beautiful, but requires care to reach maximum lifespan.
Metal Roofing — 40 to 70 Years
Includes standing seam, corrugated panels, and exposed fastener types
Highly durable and resistant to rot, insects, and fire
Proper installation and occasional inspection ensure long life
Key Takeaway: High upfront cost but exceptional longevity, often outlasting several asphalt roof cycles.
Tile Roofs (Clay or Concrete) — 50 to 100+ Years
Extremely durable and fire-resistant
Lifespan depends on underlayment quality and proper installation
Broken tiles are easy to replace if caught early
Key Takeaway: One of the longest-lasting residential roofs; maintenance focuses on replacing individual tiles, not the whole roof.
Slate — 75 to 150+ Years
Natural stone; incredibly long-lasting
Properly installed slate roofs can last well over a century
Requires skilled installation and professional inspections
Key Takeaway: Slate is essentially a lifetime roof if maintained correctly, though initial costs are high.
get a free quote for your roof today
Doesn’t matter what type of roof you have, we will connect you with contractors that are experience in your specific roof material.